Charles Becker Pays the Price
New York Police Lt. Charles Becker has been called “the crookedest cop in America”. Novelist Stephen Crane claimed that he observed Becker as a young patrolman beating up prostitutes and taking change from them when they would not pay him for allowing them to operate on his beat. The New York Board of Police Commissioners charged him with making false arrests on several occasions. Becker also tried to cover up an accidental shooting of an innocent bystander during a police pursuit. This cover-up almost cost him his badge.
In 1912, Charles Becker outdid himself. He ordered the murder of Herman Rosenthal. Rosenthal was reporting Becker’s shakedown operation to District Attorney Charles Whitman. Whitman intended to charge Becker with graft and corruption.
After the murder on July 16, 1912, several of his co-conspirators began to fear that they may be next. “Billiard Ball” Jack Rose was the first to break. Rose turned himself into Whitman and revealed that Becker had ordered Rosenthal’s death.
A few days later on July 25, 1912, the former head of the “Italian Squad”, Detective Frank Upton, captured Frank Cirofici, one of Rosenthal’s killers. Within a couple of days, the other three gunmen were captured. Based on the information that Rose and other provided, Whitman had Becker indicted for murder on July 30, 1912.
In a surreal scene, Whitman’s special investigators went to the police station, where Becker had been assigned to desk duty. After being informed that he was being arrested, the investigators sat and waited for an hour as Becker completed his shift. Becker went with the detectives, was arraigned on the charges and taken to jail.
Charles Becker and the four assassins were convicted of Rosenthal’s murder. The four assassins were executed in Sing Sing Prison on April 13, 1914. Becker was tried three times after the appeals court held that the judge in the first trial was prejudiced towards Becker and his defense. Becker was convicted by all three juries.
Some of the most damaging information was the fact that Becker was near the Hotel Metropole twenty minutes before the murder. The July 20, 1912 edition of the New York Tribune carried an artist rendering of the scene.
Charles Becker was executed on July 30, 1915 at Sing Sing Prison. His strong body and botched electrocution made his execution extremely painful. Charles Whitman had been elected Governor and refused to commute Becker’s sentence.
Because Becker was convicted primarily by testimony from criminals, a large volume of conspiracy literature has sprung up around the case since 1927. I explain why I don’t agree with this conspiracy theory in a recent podcast. Several of these books are available on Amazon.Pin It