Episode 79 – Flying Muldoon Style

it-was-almost-real-podcast-art

In this episode, I discuss William Muldoon wrestling a contest that was not much of a contest. Between falls, Muldoon demonstrated his system of physical training. WWE put on their first disappointing card of the Paul Levesque era with Elimination Chamber 2025. The last ride of the Over the Hill Gang ruined an underwhelming card. In the history segment, I […]

» Read more

Episode 77 – Don’t Call Me Barney!

it-was-almost-real-podcast-art

In this episode, we discuss Bernarr MacFadden’s professional wrestling career in St. Louis, Missouri. Update I discuss a recent email and provide an update on the Divided Championship project. Main Content For years, I could not find any account of Bernarr MacFadden’s exploits as a professional wrestler in St. Louis. While research the beginnings of what would become Tom Packs’ […]

» Read more

Episode 76 – Solving the Masked Marvel

masked-marvel-in-1915

In this episode, I discuss Ed “Strangler” Lewis defeating the Masked Marvel during the 1915 New York International Wrestling Tournament. Update After years of looking for Bernarr MacFadden’s wrestling matches in St. Louis, I stumbled across a reporter’s recollections of the best wrestling matches he covered during his twenty year career. MacFadden wrestled as B.A. McFadden in St. Louis. I […]

» Read more

George Baptiste Beats Turner’s Champion

george-baptiste-st-louis-professional-wrestler-and-referee

On April 24, 1889, the Missouri Gymnasium hosted its annual event to highlight the athletic accomplishments of its members. Members showed off gymnastic skills and other athletic ability while an orchestra or the Ideal Banjo Club played music in the background. The gymnasium managers booked a main attraction for the evening. George Baptiste, a St. Louis middleweight wrestler who specialized […]

» Read more

Whistler Wrestles Dufur in New York

clarence-whistler-greco-roman-wrestling-specialist-in-early-1880s

On Thursday, March 31, 1881, 200 fans filtered into New York’s Turnverein Hall to watch Clarence Whistler wrestle Henry Moses Dufur in a three-out-of-five-falls catch-as-catch-can wrestling match with both wrestlers wearing jackets. The promoters used the rules and jackets to try to remove any competitive advantage for either wrestler. Clarence Whistler specialized in Greco-Roman wrestling. Whistler took World Heavyweight Wrestling […]

» Read more

Episode 64 – St. Louis’ First Pro Wrestler

george-baptiste-st-louis-professional-wrestler-and-referee

In this episode, I discuss the professional wrestling and refereeing career of St. Louis’ first professional wrestler, George Baptiste. Update With this episode, we will now be a weekly podcast. We may do review episodes occasionally. Dan will also be returning to the show in two weeks. Shooter in a Worked World: John Pesek and the 1920s Promotional Wars is […]

» Read more

McLaughlin Wrestles Dufur

artist-rendering- james-hiram-mclaughlin-in-1887-for-allen-ginter-cigarettes

On Thursday, October 7, 1884, Colonel James Hiram McLaughlin wrestled Henry Moses Dufur for what both men claimed would be the last time. The 40-year-olds specialized in collar-and-elbow wrestling. The men wrestled in Detroit, Michigan, the home territory of McLaughlin. The match took place at the Detroit Opera House in front of a small crowd. Professional wrestling had not developed […]

» Read more

McLaughlin Defends Title?

artist-rendering- james-hiram-mclaughlin-in-1887-for-allen-ginter-cigarettes

On Tuesday, January 29, 1884, approximately two thousand fans crowded into the Detroit Opera House to watch the first of a two-match series between Colonel James H. McLaughlin and Henry Moses Dufur. The crowd had to delight the organizers and wrestlers. Matches drawing crowds in the thousands were rare during the 19th Century. Organizers claimed McLaughlin was defending the American […]

» Read more

Episode 46 – Muldoon vs. Whistler

clarence-whistler-wrestling-william-muldoon

In this episode, we discuss William Muldoon vs. Clarence Whistler as we try to be more positive this week. Update We only spend a few minutes talking about the Vince McMahon scandal. I make a book recommendation, Ken Patera: Weight of the World (affiliate link), and share a few stories about my dad, Ernest Charles Diaz. Main Content I realized […]

» Read more

Henry Moses Dufur Reminiscences

henry-moses-dufur-article

Henry Moses Dufur held the World Heavyweight Collar-and-Elbow Wrestling Champion during the 1870s. By 1885, Dufur retired from professional wrestling to pursue his full-time profession of clothing tailor. Even during his wrestling career, Dufur worked as a tailor. Dufur told the correspondent from The Boston Globe that he was born in Richford, Vermont on June 5, 1843. This date of […]

» Read more
1 2 3 4 10